|
Randomized comparative study of
therapeutic paracentesis with and without intravenous albumin in cirrhosis.
Gines P, Tito L, Arroyo V,
Planas R, Panes J, Viver J, Torres M, Humbert P, Rimola A, Llach J, et
al.
Gastroenterology 1988
Jun;94(6):1493-502
It has recently been shown that repeated
large-volume paracentesis associated with intravenous albumin infusion is a
rapid, effective, and safe therapy of ascites in cirrhosis. To investigate
whether intravenous albumin infusion is necessary in the treatment of cirrhotics
with large-volume paracentesis, 105 patients with tense ascites were randomly
allocated into two groups. Fifty-two patients (group 1) were treated with
paracentesis (4-6 L/day until disappearance of ascites) plus intravenous albumin
infusion (40 g after each tap), and 53 (group 2) with paracentesis without
albumin infusion. After disappearance of ascites, patients were discharged from
the hospital with diuretics. Patients developing tense ascites during follow-up
were treated according to their initial schedule. Paracentesis was effective in
eliminating the ascites in 50 patients from group 1 and in 48 from group 2, with
the duration of the hospital stay being approximately 11 days in both groups.
Paracentesis plus intravenous albumin did not induce significant changes in
standard renal function tests, plasma renin activity, and plasma aldosterone. In
contrast, paracentesis without albumin was associated with a significant
increase in blood urea nitrogen, a marked elevation in plasma renin activity and
plasma aldosterone concentration, and a significant reduction in serum sodium
concentration. One patient from group 1 and 11 from group 2 developed renal
impairment or severe hyponatremia after treatment, or both (chi 2 = 9.19; p less
than 0.01). The development of these complications could not be predicted by
clinical and laboratory data before treatment. Although the probability of
survival after entry into the study was similar in patients from both groups, a
multivariate analysis identified the development of hyponatremia or renal
impairment, or both, following the first paracentesis treatment and the
occurrence of other complications during the first hospitalization
(encephalopathy, gastrointestinal bleeding, and severe infection) as being the
only independent predictors of mortality. These results indicate that
intravenous albumin infusion is important in avoiding renal and electrolyte
complications and activation of endogenous vasoactive systems in cirrhotics with
ascites who are treated with repeated large-volume paracentesis. The development
of such complications may impair survival in these patients.
|